Bagels were delicious, first time trying here. Garlic and everything bagels w egg and cheese hit the spot and their fountain soda is AMAZING. Very friendly staff and warm atmosphere walking in.

Great bagels, great service, great experience! The staff was so nice and helpful through my indecisive behavior ha! They have so many great options. All of which, are made in house. The bagels are always fresh and they never sell "day olds". This is true, east coast style bagels. I love the location and staff. Their bagels are a MUST try!

Appreciate a local spot nearby. Selections are plentiful. My SO and I had various sweet and salty combos including a lox one and a breakfast sando one. All were decent. But nothing that truly wowed us. The bagels were tougher than what I'm used to from going to NYC frequently.

We came to Indy for a night and before we left town this morning I wanted to find a good bagel. The bagel shop local to us went out business a couple years ago, and we miss them desperately. We stopped in Bagel Fair because I saw good reviews on Yelp and TikTok. My husband ordered an everything bagel with bacon, egg, pepper jack, and jalapeno cheddar cream cheese. I ordered an everything bagel with just the jalapeno cheddar cream cheese. This was our usual order at or local place and Bagel Fair did not disappoint! The bagels were perfect. Slightly crispy on the outside, soft with a little chewiness on the inside. The cream cheese had a nice jalapeno flavor without being overwhelming with the heat. I'm just sad they are a couple hours away! We do go to Nora occasionally for the apothecary, and Bagel Fair will be an added stop every time now.

This is the place for a real bagel. Hot, fresh, service is great. I really like the new store just a couple doors down from the original location. It's tucked out of the way and I seem to forget about this place and rediscover it. Always wonder why I don't come back more often. The old place used to be run by a Jewish couple and their family. Not sure if it is still owned by them, but the quality of the bagels have not changed. I'd put them up against any you would get in New York. Nice thick smear of cream cheese- delicious. I had one of their breakfast sandwiches recently, and it was delicious as well. Expect a line- people line up for these. But they are super fast and it moves quick.

Not too many fresh bagel shops in Indiana. I had always wanted to come try this place. It's about 30 plus minutes north of my home. They also close early, 2pm. I got a dozen bagels everything, cranberry apple and jalenpeno and cheese. The service is quick and easy. Whether you order bagels to go or a sandwich they are fast and efficient. There is no seating to eat your bagel, but the place looked very clean. I definitely will be back.

Wow this place IS good! It's my new favorite place for bagels. They have a lot of cream cheese varieties and bagel options. The sesame seed bagel with scallion cream cheese was very good. There was a generous amount of cream cheese and it had a good flavor. The egg and pepper jack cheese sandwich on an everything bagel was good. Although their cream cheese bagel was the best of the bunch. Employees were working with a sense of urgency and service was fast, even for how busy they were on a weekday morning. Order at the counter and wait for your order. There is no seating inside. Parking was plentiful as they're located in a large shopping center.

When you are craving a bagel for breakfast, Bagel Fair is the only place to go! Located in Nora plaza, they have recently renovated inside and added classy new signage on the outside - but that's not as important as their fresh and perfectly crafted bagels in a variety of flavors (Onion, Garlic, Sesame, Jalapeño, Everything, Cranberry Apple, Cinnamon Raisin, to name a few!) My personal favorite is a Cinnamon Raisin with Cinnamon cream cheese, or if I'm craving savory, an Everything bagel with plain cream cheese. Don't ask for your bagel to be toasted because they don't have a toaster! I thought at first this was an oversight, but no - the bagels are so fresh and perfectly tender on the inside, shiny and slightly crisp on the outside you can skip the toaster altogether (or take it home with cream cheese on the side if you really need that extra browning). The staff is always friendly and fast, and you can't beat the current price of $1.50 per bagel! Make sure you stop by before they sell out for the day!

How things have changed since 2012! New location (same strip mall) and credit cards now accepted. Still hot, fresh bagels that smell and taste amazing. Still no toaster because the bagels are perfect as is. Get here early because when they're sold out, they close for the day.